AiR-RadioheaD.CoM > RADIOHEAD
How to Disappear: a portrait of Radiohead by Colin Greenwood
hunting android:
--- Citation de: LaFrip le lun. 30 septembre 2024, 11:40:01 ---Il aurait tellement mérité une édition collector 20 ans malgré ce que beaucoup en pense.
--- Fin de citation ---
Le groupe n'aime pas beaucoup l'album non plus.
Radiohead have criticised Hail to the Thief. In 2006, Yorke told Spin: "I'd maybe change the playlist. I think we had a meltdown when we put it together ... We wanted to do things quickly, and I think the songs suffered."[92] In 2008, Yorke posted an alternative track listing on Radiohead's website, omitting "Backdrifts", "We Suck Young Blood", "I Will" and "A Punchup at a Wedding".[6] In an interview with Mojo, O'Brien said Radiohead should have cut the album to ten tracks and that its length had alienated some listeners, and Colin Greenwood said several songs were unfinished and that the album was "a holding process".[93] Jonny agreed that it was too long, and said: "We were trying to do what people said we were good at ... But it was good for our heads. It was good for us to be doing a record that came out of playing live."[93]
In 2013, Godrich told NME: "I think there's some great moments on there – but too many songs ... As a whole I think it's charming because of the lack of editing. But personally it's probably my least favourite of all the albums ... It didn't really have its own direction. It was almost like a homogeny of previous work. Maybe that's its strength
astyl120:
les lives de cette période étaient plutôt bons
the_thief:
Je suis d’accord avec Thom.
Mais rien que pour Where i end and you begin j’aime quand même cet album.
hunting android:
C'est un album avec lequel j'entretiens un rapport assez compliqué.
Déjà, il arrive après la trilogie Ok computer/Kid A/ Amnesiac ce qui est déjà lourd à porter.
Et je l'ai effectivement trouvé trop long ou en tout cas qu'il comportait trop de titres dont certains assez moyens (Backdrift, We suck young blood, Scatterbrain, Punch up...) et je suis pas un grand fan du travail de Nigel sur celui-là.
Je le réhabilite avec les années, je l'écoute beaucoup ces derniers temps (dans la version réduite de Thom).
ça aurait pas été inintéressant de le ressortir en version courte, en retravaillant un peu les transitions et avec un second disque de face B mais ça aurait été surement invendable de commercialiser une version courte d'un album qui existe déjà...Après il y avait moyen de faire une chouette édition collector, les artworks de l'époque étaient cools en plus. et c'est le seul album restant avec the bends et pablo à ne pas avoir une box dédiée.
Visiblement, ils ont préféré taffer sur The Bends pour les 30 ans, et il y a de quoi faire donc bon:
The Trickster
Punchdrunk Lovesick Singalong
Lozenge Of Love
Lewis (Mistreated)
Permanent Daylight
You Never Wash Up After Yourself (Live)
Maquiladora
Killer Cars
India Rubber
How Can You Be Sure
Talk Show Host
Bishop's Robes
Banana Co
Molasses
Pour HTTT, quand on retire les remix et versions live, il y a moins à manger, 4 ou 5 face b peut être?
LaFrip:
--- Citation de: hunting android le lun. 30 septembre 2024, 11:53:51 ---Le groupe n'aime pas beaucoup l'album non plus.
Radiohead have criticised Hail to the Thief. In 2006, Yorke told Spin: "I'd maybe change the playlist. I think we had a meltdown when we put it together ... We wanted to do things quickly, and I think the songs suffered."[92] In 2008, Yorke posted an alternative track listing on Radiohead's website, omitting "Backdrifts", "We Suck Young Blood", "I Will" and "A Punchup at a Wedding".[6] In an interview with Mojo, O'Brien said Radiohead should have cut the album to ten tracks and that its length had alienated some listeners, and Colin Greenwood said several songs were unfinished and that the album was "a holding process".[93] Jonny agreed that it was too long, and said: "We were trying to do what people said we were good at ... But it was good for our heads. It was good for us to be doing a record that came out of playing live."[93]
In 2013, Godrich told NME: "I think there's some great moments on there – but too many songs ... As a whole I think it's charming because of the lack of editing. But personally it's probably my least favourite of all the albums ... It didn't really have its own direction. It was almost like a homogeny of previous work. Maybe that's its strength
--- Fin de citation ---
Je sais bien qu'eux même n'en sont pas satisfaits.
Moi je l'aime bcp.
J'aime bien également la tracklist choisie pour la version épurée, même si j'aime bien Backdrifts & We suck.
Mais moins que celles gardées (à part peut-être Go to sleep qui ne m'a jamais fait chavirer).
2+2, Sit down, Where I end, There there et Myxomato. sont des pièces très importantes je trouve de leur disco.
Navigation
[#] Page suivante
[*] Page précédente
Utiliser la version classique